The Bill of Rights for Creator Subscriptions

Every major platform now wants to run your subscription business. Competition is good for creators, but only if creators know how to evaluate what they need.

‍

The terms you accept today decide whether you own a business or rent an audience.

‍

Below are seven rights a creator should expect from any subscription platform. If a platform can't say yes to all seven, ask why.

‍

1. You own the customer relationship

The person paying you is your customer. You’ve been cultivating that relationship with free content for months, if not years before “going paid”. No platform should have the power to disintermediate you at this point. 

‍

That means their payment method is stored under an account you control, it's your name that appears on credit card statements and you have the power to contact them whenever you please.

‍

2. You can leave, and take your subscribers with you

Exporting a list of names is not portability. Real portability means the paying relationship moves intact - subscribers keep their plan and renewal date, and nobody has to re-enter a credit card.

‍

A platform that controls the payments has the most powerful form of lock-in. The fear of churn at migration is the switching cost, and they know it.

‍

3. You get all your data, not just a dashboard

You can't run a business on a summary screen. You should have subscriber-level access to:

• Email addresses and contact details
• Plan, price, subscription date, payment status, churn
• Consumption data - which episodes get played the most and by who
• Raw exports on demand, plus an API so your other tools can read it

‍

4. You can meet subscribers where they are

Audio, video, newsletters, community, livestreams. The same fan might want to listen while working out, watch on TV during the evenings and read updates on busy days. Creators shouldn't have to stitch together different vendors to deliver the premium experience that their fans deserve, wherever they want it. 

‍

5. An exclusive room, not a shopping mall

Your fans are paying to get more of you. So you should control that experience end to end, and no one else gets to market to them without your say-so.

‍

No app they're pushed to download. No feed putting your show next to everyone else's. No "creators you may like" email landing in the inbox of someone who already chose you. A platform that serves your subscribers should want nothing from them except that they stay subscribed to you. Anything beyond that is yours to offer, not theirs to take.

‍

6. Your business, your brand

Your subscribers should be going deeper with your brand, not your vendor's. The signup page, the checkout, the receipts, the membership, the domain: each one should lead with your brand.

‍

If a fan has to name your brand and the underlying platform in the same breath, that company is assimilating your brand equity in service of its own growth.

‍

7. A partner, not a landlord

When a subscriber isn’t getting what they expected, it’s hard for them to stay a superfan. So responsive subscriber support isn't a back-office function, it's part of your product.

‍

A true partner to creators also shows up with launch playbooks, growth recommendations and honest benchmarks. Platforms should only make more money when you do, and that should drive how they show up for you and your subscribers.

‍

The test

Ask these questions before you sign:

1. Who is the merchant of record on my subscribers' credit card statements?
2. If I leave, do my subscribers' payment methods come with me - or do they have to re-subscribe?
3. Can I export every subscriber's email address today, and may I email them?
4. What is my net revenue on a $5 monthly plan, on web and in-app?
5. Will you ever show my paying subscribers another creator's content?
6. Who at your company will know my show's name a year from now?

‍

And one more time: beware platform lock-in. It rarely looks like a bad deal on the day you sign. That only comes out when you want to leave and find that the relationship, the data and the billing were never really yours.

‍